So, a book that discusses the symbolism of the great gatsby is a secondary source. Secondary sources are those that analyze primary sources and may consist of books, newspaper articles, web sites, or statistics. I have been asked to critique my primary and secondary sources at the end of my paper. Secondary sources history research guides at lansing. Are there one or more secondary books that the author seems to lean heavily on in support of the argument. In a wellwritten essay, the thesis is usually clearly stated near the beginning of the piece. Humanities writers should avoid referencing any tertiary information in their research papers. A secondary source interprets and analyzes primary sources.
Historians accounts are usually called secondary sources, in order to distinguish them from the primary source material on which they are based. Interested in reading more about primary source vs. You will then use this source to discuss how it relates to your argument about the primary source. One of the first actions of a marketing consultant involves identifying the desired market and determining the market potential berkowitz, 2006. The life of lady mary wortley montagu by robert halsband, star trek. A secondary source describes, interprets, or synthesizes primary sources. How we apply meaning to a primary source is rarely static, it shifts and evolves over time. They can therefore take into consideration other events and place a primary source in its historical context. It suggests a hierarchy of importance, with secondary writings ranking less highly than primary sources. Typically this is a recently written book that describes past events, often written by a historian or trained scholar familiar about the time period and civilization in question. Secondary sources often lack the freshness and immediacy of the original material. It is intended to serve the needs of teachers and students in college survey courses in modern european history and american history, as well as in modern western civilization and world cultures. A good secondary source uses primary sources as evidence. Secondary data analysis is the analysis of data that was collected by someone else.
Primary vs secondary sources explained with easy examples. On the other hand, personal knowledge in history can be seen as the way we, as individuals, interpret the. Generally, secondary sources are used for three main reasons. How you use a source determines whether it is a primary source or secondary source. Not sure what makes a hsc modern history historical source useful or reliable. They can cover the same topic, but add a layer of interpretation and analysis. Now that you can tell the difference between primary source vs.
What can be the values and limitations of a source. Primary, secondary, and tertiary sources university of. A secondary source contrasts with a primary source, which is an original source of the information being discussed. A secondary source is a secondhand account or interpretation, opinion, or analysis of an event. There are six analysis skills that you need to master. Secondary sources offer an analysis, interpretation or a restatement of primary sources and are considered to be persuasive. They often attempt to describe or explain primary sources. Often, the most difficult task when reading a secondary source is to identify the authors thesis. Analysis and evaluation of educational experimentation in journals, pamphlets, books, and. Get an answer for what can be the values and limitations of a source. Another type of secondary source is a scholarly journal article. Apr, 2020 a biology textbook would be considered a secondary source if in the field of biology, since it describes and interprets the science but makes no original contribution to it. How to read a secondary source history college of liberal.
Databases help you identify articles in scholarly journals or books on a particular. For a historical research project, secondary sources are generally scholarly books and articles. Are there important issues that the author cannot address based on these sources. Simple plot summaries, synopses, other basic descriptions of a works contents are generally primary sources. In a long article or book, the thesis is usually diffuse. Not sure how to actually get 1010 marks for a source analysis in hsc modern history. These sources offer an analysis or restatement of primary sources. In historiography, a secondary source is a study written by a scholar about a topic. Scholars generally use the term secondary source to refer to books, sections. Reading secondary historical sources is a skill which may be acquired and must be practiced. Secondary sources provide secondhand information and commentary from other researchers.
Secondary sources analyze a scholarly question and often use primary sources as evidence. Primary and secondary sources history department libguides at. This allowed me to effectively link hardboiled narration to the philosophy of noir, and established my credibility for the reader. On the other hand, if the topic is science education and the history of textbooks, textbooks could be used a primary sources to look at how they have changed over time. Apr 12, 2019 researchers certainly incorporate secondary sources into their scholarship. When you cite someone whos writing about a primary source, thats what called a secondary source.
History colloquium secondary source analysis assignment a 2page paper doublespaced, 12point times roman, oneinch margins on the article by robert m. Your bibliography helps readers see what sources you used to make your claims and your argument. Data, whether primary or secondary, should be current and relevant. Secondary sources history 165 research guides at williams. Feb 19, 2015 this video defines a primary source and what makes it different from a secondary source. The distinction between types of sources can get tricky, because a secondary source may also be a primary source. A primary source is a document that was created at the time of the event or subject youve chosen to study or by people who. If exploring how an event affected people at a certain time, this type of source would be considered a primary source. Secondary sources describe, discuss, interpret, comment upon, analyze, evaluate, summarize, and process primary sources. In history, common secondary sources include books and journal articles that argue for a certain interpretation of history. Secondary source these sources are translated, repackaged, restated, analyzed, or interpreted original information that is a primary source. Library guide to the history of science your guide to the history of science at harvard. Garry wills book about lincolns gettysburg address, for example, can looked at as both a secondary and a primary source.
Secondary sources describe, analyse, interpret or draw conclusions from a primary source. Instead, textbook authors usually rely on secondary sources written by other historians. Do these sources allow the author to adequately explore the subject. Primary sources contain firsthand knowledge of events and people and are essential to a good research project. A news article may be treated as a primary source e. It may offer a new reading of historical events and primary sources that have been analyzed before, or present an analysis of events and sources that were previously unknown or not written about. A secondary source is a book or article that analyzes the primary sources written by and for. British history online is a digital library of key printed primary and secondary sources for the history of britain and ireland, with a primary focus on the period between 0 and 1800. Frequently, they also take advantage of the work of other historians by using other secondary sources. National history day, an annual program for elementary and secondary students designed to teach essential historical literacy that motivates students to secure the future of democracy, defines secondary sources as follows. To determine whether a book is a primary source or a secondary source, a person needs to know what a primary and secondary source is.
Thorough examination of available primary and secondary sources allows. A secondary source, then, is a source that has also done analysis of the same or a similar topic. Apr 06, 2020 a secondary source is a book or article that analyzes the primary sources written by and for other researchers. First, a primary source, define by princeton, is a document or physical object which was written or created during the time under study. On occasion, secondary sources will collect, organize. Secondary sources involve generalization, analysis, synthesis, interpretation, or evaluation of the original information. Reading academic material well is an active process that can be far removed from the kind of pleasure reading most of us are used to. A short history of its people and politics by martin ewans, afghanistan by stephen tanner, the death of. They often involve generalisation, synthesis, interpretation, commentary or evaluation in an attempt to convince the reader of the creators argument. The goal of the essay is to explain what citino arguesand why and how. These are much shorter than books, but also much more specific.
Feb 04, 2020 secondary sources analyze a scholarly question and often use primary sources as evidence. How to read a secondary source history college of liberal arts. Weve got you covered with a step by step guide to writing a 1010 hsc modern history source analysis. A thesis is the controlling argument of a work of history. Primary sources can be original documents such as letters, speeches, diaries, creative works such as art, novels, music and film, published materials of the times newspapers, magazines, memoirs, etc. A secondary source is generally one or more steps removed from the event or time period and are written or produced after the fact with the benefit of hindsight. How to write a 1010 hsc modern history source analysis. All analyses and interpretive or synthetic claims about primary sources must be referenced to a secondary or tertiary source, and must not be an original analysis of the primary source material by wikipedia editors.
Primary sources provide evidence and also allow us to apply meaning. What should these critiques focus on and how long should they be. Use these worksheets for photos, written documents, artifacts, posters, maps, cartoons, videos, and sound recordings to teach your students the process of document analysis. This video is about learning how to analyze primary sources. The key to determining whether an item may be considered to be a primary source is to ask how soon after the event was the information recorded. Secondary sources are invaluable to sociologists, but they have to be. Analyzing a primary source is like conducting an investigation you have to. A primary source is an original material created during the time under study.
A secondary source would be a book on th century politics, while the magna carta itself would be a primary source. A secondary source is a work that comments on the past. Secondary sources sources for historical research guides at. A secondary source is a document or recording that writes or speaks about information that is one step removed from the original source the secondary source depends on the primary source or original source of the information. Primary sources include original documents, data, creative works, and objects that are often the subject of analysis by secondary works. And, multiple conflicting interpretations can exist simultaneously and almost.
Secondary sources include books and articles about a topic. Teach your students to think through primary source documents for contextual understanding and to extract information to make informed judgments. The distinction may depend on how you are using the source and the nature of. For example, the author of the history textbook which you use in school probably did not use too many primary sources.
Secondary sources are works of synthesis and interpretation based upon primary sources and the work of other. Writing critiques of primary and secondary sources. Dont read a history book as if you were reading a novel for light pleasure reading. Thorough examination of available primary and secondary sources allows students to construct their own analysis related to the impact and significance of their topics in history. The collection and analysis of primary sources is central to historical research. A secondary source is a document or recording that relates or discusses information originally presented elsewhere. Good secondary sources are based on the interpretation of a wide variety of primary sources. In scholarship, a secondary source is a document or recording that relates or discusses information originally presented elsewhere. Secondary sources in history and humanities are usually books or scholarly journals, from the perspective of a later interpreter, especially by a later scholar. Sure, history may sometimes be dry, but youll find success reading even the most difficult material if you can master these skills.
Analysis is the ability to demonstrate an understanding of the elements that contributed to the creation of a historical source. Primary and secondary sources research 101 libguides. Reading secondary historical sources is a skill which may be acquired and must be. Primary source examples letters, diaries, memoirs, interviews, poems published or unpublished. Secondary or tertiary sources are needed to establish the topics notability and to avoid novel interpretations of primary sources.
Secondary sources were created by someone who did not experience firsthand or participate in the events or conditions youre researching. Primary and secondary sources historical sources can be divided. Jun 20, 2018 if you use the movie for background information or analysis about your topic for example, to learn about a historical event or a scientific discovery the movie is a secondary source. Using a variety of secondary sources provides students with multiple perspectives, exposing them to a variety of opinions and interpretations. Legal secondary sources are texts that provide commentary and analysis of the law for the benefit of the reader. Secondary sources are one step removed from primary sources, though they often quote or otherwise use primary sources. Here are some examples that are often used as secondary sources. A secondary source is a mediary between you and the primary source. Sometimes it is difficult to determine whether a source is primary or secondary. They often try to describe or explain primary sources. Using secondary sources academic writing research guides. Even so, this page offers some useful suggestions for students looking to start their source analysis papers. That being said, we should subject secondary sources to the same scrutiny as we do primary material. Primary and secondary sources research 101 libguides at.
However, secondary source is not an entirely satisfactory term. Secondary sources are invaluable to sociologists, but they have. Typically, one secondary source is used, but i used two. You wont find a complete biography of nelson mandela in a scholarly journal article, but rather an analysis of a specific part of his life or work. It has more extensive lists of resources and tools than this introductory guide does. We aim to support the learning, teaching and research of our users from around the world. The internet modern history sourcebook is one of series of history primary sourcebooks.
What type of source is most important in the argument. A secondary source might also synthesize the work of other historians in order to formulate a. Secondary sources can include history books, articles, websites like this one other websites might be a primary source to contemporary history. Primary and secondary categories are often not fixed and depend on the study or research you are undertaking. Secondary sources are created after the studied eventwork took place or the studied work was created. We build on the ideas of others and the interpretation of a primary source is often contested. Secondary sources are used in introductions to establish ethos as well as to provide a smooth transition into the connector.
Secondary sources interpret, evaluate or discuss information found in primary sources. Primary sources are more credible as evidence, but good research uses both primary and secondary sources. And, as has been noted earlier, most books dealing with. Primary sources and secondary sources what is a primary source. Some specialized humanities encyclopedias available through the gsis library are an exception to this guideline. Many secondary sources use extensive citations in the form of footnotes or endnotes. For example, newspaper editorialopinion pieces can be both primary and secondary. Nov 21, 2019 secondary sources can include history books, articles, websites like this one other websites might be a primary source to contemporary history. Because it is an argument, it is subject to evaluation and analysis. The main use of secondary sources in law is to explain the law. You can use the cited reference search in web of science to find secondary source articles that cite a specified secondary or primary source article or book.
Primary and secondary sources unofficialfactchecker. Document analysis is the first step in working with primary sources. Newspaper reports, news magazines, political journals and newsletters, journal articles, history books, dictionaries, encyclopedias, textbooks, journal articles, biographies, commentaries on a speech, analyses of election data. Popular secondary source books goodreads share book. They tend to be works which summarize, interpret, reorganize, or otherwise provide an added value to a primary source. Secondary source simple english wikipedia, the free. The writing center explains how and when it is appropriate to cite secondary sources. Your bibliography helps readers see what sources you. Thus, the information comes to us secondhand, or through at least one filter. Secondary source analysis tennessee state university. If youre looking specifically for historical resources, read how to find primary sources for your history essay. Historical writing is as much a reflection of its authors. Most importantly, critique the historical argument. Students who are constructing longer source analysis essays or research papers especially in upperdivision history courses, should also look at the paper writing study aid, which contains more complete advice for such assignments.
678 1194 697 402 422 534 483 270 116 596 1542 925 991 369 1199 748 1365 245 365 1394 1633 1397 1086 477 399 282 927 1487 1373 1145 739 414 844 1015